INTRODUCTION
Local Government Areas (LGAs) in Nigeria were designed to be the third tier of government, closest to the people, and responsible for grassroots development. However, decades after the 1976 Local Government Reforms, many LGAs remain weak, inefficient, and financially dependent on state governments. This article examines the reasons behind the weakness of LGAs in Nigeria and the implications for governance and development.
Local government areas (LGAs) are meant to bring governance closer to the people, facilitate grassroots development, and serve as a critical bridge between citizens and higher levels of government. However, despite their potential and constitutional status, LGAs in Nigeria remain institutionally weak, financially dependent, and politically manipulated.
The Nigerian local government system has long been criticized for its inefficiency and lack of autonomy.
Local governments in Nigeria have struggled to deliver basic services and promote grassroots development. The question remains: Why are local governments so weak in Nigeria?
This article explores the core reasons behind the persistent weakness of LGAs and the ongoing struggle for true autonomy.
HISTORICAL AND CONSTITUTIONAL FOUNDATIONS
The 1976 Local Government Reform initiated under the military regime marked a pivotal moment for LGAs in Nigeria. It aimed to grant them a measure of autonomy, with elected officials and direct access to federal allocations. However, the 1999 Constitution, while recognizing LGAs under Section 7, placed them under the control of state governments—particularly through the creation and operation of State Joint Local Government Accounts (SJLGA) under Section 162(6). This arrangement has allowed state governors to exercise significant influence over LGA finances and decision-making.
REASONS FOR LGA'S WEAKNESS.
1. Constitutional Ambiguity and State Government Control
One of the primary reasons for the weakness of LGAs is the constitutional framework that leaves them vulnerable to state government interference. While the 1999 Constitution (as amended) recognizes LGAs as a tier of government, Section 7 grants state governments the power to legislate on their structure, finance, and administration.
State governments often exploit this provision by:
- Withholding LGA allocations from the Federation Account.
- Appointing caretaker committees instead of allowing democratically elected officials.
- Controlling LGA funds through State Joint Local Government Accounts (SJLGA), which are often mismanaged.
According to BudgIT (2022), over 60% of LGAs in Nigeria do not receive their full allocations due to state government interference.
2. Lack of Financial Autonomy
The Financial Autonomy Bill, which sought to grant LGAs direct access to their funds, has faced stiff resistance from state governors. Instead, LGAs rely on monthly allocations from the Federation Account, which are often delayed or diverted.
A 2021 report by the Nigeria Governors’ Forum (NGF) revealed that many states deduct arbitrary percentages from LGA funds for "administrative costs," leaving LGAs with little to execute projects.
3. Poor Governance and Corruption
Even when funds are available, mismanagement and corruption at the LGA level undermine development. Many LGAs lack:
- Transparent budgeting processes
- Accountability mechanisms
- Citizen participation in governance
The Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) has prosecuted several LGA officials for embezzlement, yet systemic corruption persists.
4. Over-Politicization of LGA Elections
Unlike federal and state elections conducted by the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC), LGA elections are controlled by State Independent Electoral Commissions (SIECs), which are often manipulated by state governors.
A 2020 report by Yiaga Africa found that over 80% of LGA elections in Nigeria are non-competitive, with ruling parties winning all seats in most states. This undermines democracy and weakens LGAs’ ability to function independently.
5. Weak Capacity and Bureaucratic Inefficiency
Many LGAs lack the technical expertise to implement projects effectively. Poor staffing, inadequate training, and outdated administrative structures hinder service delivery.
The World Bank (2019) noted that only 30% of Nigerian LGAs have functional development plans, leading to haphazard project execution.
Several studies and reports have highlighted the need for local government autonomy in Nigeria. According to a report by the Nigerian Governors' Forum, granting full autonomy to local governments could increase their internally generated revenue by 300%. Another study by the World Bank noted that decentralization and local government autonomy are critical to promoting economic development and reducing poverty.
To strengthen local governments in Nigeria, several steps can be taken.
Firstly, the Constitution should be amended to clarify the roles and responsibilities of state and local governments.
Secondly, local governments should be granted full financial autonomy, allowing them to generate and manage their own revenue.
Finally, capacity-building programs should be implemented to enhance the skills and knowledge of local government officials.
CONCLUSION: THE WAY FORWARD
For LGAs to fulfill their constitutional mandate, the following reforms are necessary:
1. Constitutional Amendment: Remove ambiguities in the 1999 Constitution to grant full autonomy to LGAs.
2. Direct Funding: LGAs should receive allocations directly from the Federation Account, bypassing state governments.
3. Electoral Reforms: INEC should conduct LGA elections to ensure fairness.
4. Anti-Corruption Measures: Strengthen oversight mechanisms to curb financial mismanagement.
5. Capacity Building: Invest in training and modernizing LGA administrations.
Until these reforms are implemented, LGAs will remain weak, and grassroots development will continue to suffer.
REFERENCES:
- Nigerian Governors' Forum. (2018). Local Government Autonomy in Nigeria: A Review of the Constitution and Practice.
- World Bank. (2019). Decentralization and Local Governance in Nigeria: A Review of the Literature.
- Okoli, F. C. (2017). Local Government Administration in Nigeria: Challenges and Prospects. Journal of Local Government Studies, 6(1), 1-15.
- Agagu, A. A. (2020). Local Government Autonomy and Development in Nigeria: A Critical Analysis. Journal of Public Administration and Governance, 10(2), 1-12.
- BudgIT (2022). Local Government Transparency Report.
- EFCC (2023). Cases of Corruption in Local Governments.
- World Bank (2019). Assessing Local Government Performance in Nigeria.
- Yiaga Africa (2020). Report on LGA Elections in Nigeria.
Okonta Emeka Okelum is an online journalist, social analyst, governance activist, sustainable development enthusiast, and grassroot community development champion, with special focus on governance, democracy, rule of law, politics, human rights, and development in Nigeria.
Follow me on
https://www.linkedin.com/in/emeka-okelum-okonta-3a1a001a1?utm_source=share&utm_campaign=share_via&utm_content=profile&utm_medium=android_app
https://www.facebook.com/share/1ANJac82Le/
asabapost@gmail.com
0915 735 9768
No comments:
Post a Comment