Pages

Friday, June 11, 2010

UK election outcome: lessons for peacebuilding

Diana Francis

Here in the UK we are beginning to digest the outcome of our recent electoral process, which brought us a new coalition government for which no single person voted, so demonstrating the complexity of the relationship between individual actions and their combined consequences. More often than not our current system produces a clear ‘winner’, one of the two largest parties having a minority of votes but an absolute parliamentary majority and so being able to form a single-party government. Smaller parties are excluded from power and as a consequence remain small, since not all their adherents are happy to ‘waste’ their vote.  Such a system is therefore unsatisfactory in terms of both representation and pluralism.

In line with this win-lose, binary power system, and fed by it, the British style of politics is of the adversarial ‘eat or be eaten’ variety, often characterised in the House of Commons by sneering and point scoring from speakers, shouts and jeers from their audience. This is surely one of the reasons for the near invisibility of women in the election and post-election processes (paralleled by the exclusion of women journalists from key moments in the election campaign, as being inadequately pugilistic.  The inbuilt misogyny of British politics was epitomised by one male commentator – delightedly quoted by others – who likened a male politician’s behaviour to that of ‘every harlot in history’.

This macho culture has its effect. In our new parliament the number of women remains disgracefully small and only four have been appointed to the ministerial cabinet, out of 23 members, and only one of them to a key position. Lib Dem MP Lynne Featherstone, appointed to a junior ministerial role in the Home Office, told the Guardian, ‘Looking at parliament and the way it behaves, any sane woman would … say do I want to be part of this bullying, finger-pointing mob who don’t talk like human beings and are disengaged from real life?’

Just as an electoral system that is unfair to parties is undemocratic, so is a politics from whose structures, processes and power women are largely excluded. Inclusive democracy is a key constituent of positive peace. It is the true alternative to violence.  In order to work for peace it needs not only the intelligence, experience, abilities and insights of women, but also the behavioural norms and cooperative style which they are able to adopt when they work together (as against those they may use when they are trying to succeed in a men’s world).

The macho, eat or be eaten approach so evident in UK domestic politics plays out also in international affairs. It underlay the response to 9.11 and the invasion of Afghanistan, which has left so many thousands of Afghans dead, and a tragic number of occupying soldiers too. It also underlies the UK’s insistence on retaining the nuclear weapons that it denies to others. None of the three main parties here opposed the war in Afghanistan or is willing to admit their folly or promised any radically new approach to its tragic continuation. The visit to Afghanistan made in the last few days by the Coalition’s Ministers for defence, foreign affairs and international development seems to have signalled no change in policy – only an insulting, heartless and unconvincing reiteration of the primacy of UK national security interests.   Similarly, none of the three main parties took a stand against nuclear weapons. The Conservative and Labour parties both advocated the replacement of our current Trident system, whose capital cost is estimated by Greenpeace to be £34 billion. The Liberal  Democrats, claiming that the full capital and running costs would amount to £100 billion were applauded by some, derided by others, for wanting to find a cheaper alternative and pursue multilateral nuclear disarmament.  It seems this somewhat different approach has not had much impact on the essentially Tory policy adopted by the coalition government, whose defence spending looks set to remain extremely high.

The tragedy is that there was so little pre-election debate on this issue and that international affairs continue to come so low in our electoral priorities.  Despite recent shifts in public opinion on UK wars and weapons policy, established norms (reflected by the BBC and most of our newspapers) remain unchanged. The marginalisation of radical politics that is perpetuated by our electoral system contributes to this pathological conservatism. That must change. A major cultural shift is required, so that the world is seen through different lenses and the eat or be eaten approach, with its endless struggle for dominance, is replaced by cooperation, on the basis of interdependence.  We must work to make it clearer to the electorate and to our politicians that interdependence is now global.

The results of our elections have, for now at least, altered our politicians’ approach to each other, and the tone of their public utterances, which are currently civil, open and constructive. Yet there has been indignation at the formation of this new alliance, as well as approval, with understandable accusations of sell-out. There are indeed grounds for concern. For those of us whose focus is peace, none of their original policies matched our aspirations in any case and, in the words of our new Prime Minister, ‘Some policies have been lost on both sides, some have been changed and yes, we have had to find ways to deal with the issues where we profoundly disagree’.

Yet if we allow our disappointment to recede for a moment, I think this is not time for despair; indeed, some hope can be found. These are human beings who, as such, will have impure motives and ambitions. They are also, I suspect, people with a real desire to live up to the ideals embodied in their own rhetoric. We may consider that their policies are at odds with those ideals and this is ground for serious debate, but the ideals themselves - such as the ‘freedom, fairness and responsibility’ named by Nick Clegg, give a useful reference point, providing an opportunity for those who wish to hold their politicians to account. Confronting differences is necessary. But assuming some good in others increases the chance of influencing them. Having passionately held values and beliefs need not mean insulting those who disagree or refusing to take the small steps that are possible and that go in the right direction.

How can principle be married with cooperation? Can respect for people be maintained in spite of profound disagreements over analysis and policy?  This is a challenge not only for politicians but for peace activists too, who also need to work in coalition across ethical and ideological divides. Learning from this process must be one item on the peacebuilding agenda in the coming years, as we support serious attempts by politicians to deal with the difficulties honestly and constructively. Unless we stop treating our political system as a battle ground it will never be a place of gender equality and without progress towards that we shall not succeed in turning the system we currently have into a vehicle for real, constructive democracy. I hope we will see a movement here for more civilised and inclusive politics, in which the common good is the common goal. It will not be easy but it could be infinitely worthwhile.

In the meantime we must act on one of the key assumptions of nonviolence: that political responsibility does not rest only with elected politicians but also with vocal and active electorates. We must form a stronger ‘peace constituency’, both locally and nationally, keeping up the pressure for nuclear disarmament, not only for its own sake but as a crucial step in furthering the aim of global nuclear disarmament that is implicit in the NPT. Commitment to this would give our government the moral right to be heard on efforts to halt and reverse the spread of nuclear weapons. We must resist any idea that war can be justified or can bring about a safer world. And we must call for a negotiated political settlement in Afghanistan, accompanied by support of every kind for Afghans who are working for peace and justice in their country. Peace cannot be imposed from outside, only built from within.

Scilla Elworthy’s arresting article points to the power and efficacy of local actors in building peace, with examples from around the world that inspire and convince. As she points out, the current funding available to support them is derisory, especially given the astronomic levels of military spending. Her proposal for a Versailles Convention in 2018, the 100th anniversary of the disastrous Versailles Treaty, is brilliant: a shining example of the power of imagination in making change possible. I hope this idea, to end ‘humanity’s bloodiest 100 years’ with a convention to prevent them, will receive the support it deserves. The preparatory work needs to begin now. I believe that the funding for it, and for the Convention itself, should be taken out of current military budgets. This expectation should be included at the launch of the campaign.

Meanwhile, for the sake of justice and inclusion, of constructive politics at home and the advancement of global peace, we must give serious and concerted attention to ending the domination of ‘macho masculinity’ in our politics and mobilising a movement of women to claim their right to equality, not only in participation, but in defining and shaping the political ethos and process that will build inclusive democracy and a more peaceful world.

19 comments:

Anonymous said...

By doing this,that traffic can remain secure in transit.
Wholemega has been shown to down-regulate inflammatory Arachidonic Acid (AA), notably improving the balance of inflammatory AA to anti-inflammatory EPA.
(Think of all the things you’ve observed your pet actually eat.
Paleo diet is gluten, dairy, soy and preservative free.


Look at my web page :: Paleo Food List

Anonymous said...

These requests are simple and minimal, and will not
require you to hide food in your purse or briefcase when you
go out to dinner. A study has shown that
omega-3 in fish and krill oil could enhance the amount of fat calories burned in a day.
However, most reptiles will not bite unless provoked.

If this is your first time reading about the Paleo Diet, it can briefly be described like this:
lean, healthy bodies are achieved through eating like paleolithic human beings.


Also visit my website Paleo Food List

Anonymous said...

The Fox Tucson Theatre's sister theater - The Rialto - has undergone some improvements and is currently open as a concert venue; it's
scheduled for a full makeover at some point in the future.
The Vitamin Code Raw Multi - Vitamins are available in eight specialized nutritional formulas including:.

It usually comes with an assortment of coffee K-cups for you to try.
This inability to fully digest lactose may lead to bloating for some individuals.


my web blog - Paleo Food List

Anonymous said...

New and experienced Paleo cooks are looking for new creative
recipes and expanded cooking experiences. 700, that the first so-called Hohokams took
up residence in Tucson. Every single exposure, no matter how small, can
cause irritation and uncomfortable symptoms for up to 30
days. When you 'break the fast' you boost your metabolism to break down the food to
be used as energy.

Here is my website ... paleo food companies

Anonymous said...

Concentration on biomass on a large scale means a shift
in the way of thinking. Engineers from the University of
Leeds carried out a study in the United Kingdom proves this.
If you want to make energy efficient updates to your home, there's never been a better time than now to do so. 80 per square foot of building floor area can be claimed as an energy efficiency tax credit for energy efficiency improvements to commercial buildings.

my web blog biomass and bioenergy

Anonymous said...

- Keep refrigerated and unwashed until ready to
cook. Fruits are seasonal in Winter months may substitute peaches and strawberries
with grapefruits, cantaloupe or oranges.
"I don't eat anything that is a product with grains. I improved one of my weight lifting maximums by 25 pounds this week and I made sure to tell everyone in my circle.

Also visit my web page http://webdhaaba.com/index.php?do=/blog/9095/exploring-uncomplicated-paleo-diet-recipes-solutions/

Anonymous said...

For example, the perfect promise ring that you
can give to a beautiful lady is one that has a band that can come in white gold or gold, with
a diamond for a stone. Titanium was a metal first used in the aerospace
industry because of its ability to withstand high temperatures.

There is general agreement that a major leap
forward in the history of friendship rings occurred in late seventeenth and early eighteenth century
Ireland in the Galway Bay area of Western Ireland, and in particular around Claddagh and nearby
fishing villages.

Feel free to surf to my web site; mens promise rings size 7

Anonymous said...

The much larger the pearl, the rarer they are really and the much more high priced.

There are many online stores that provide you a wide variety of rings of unique designs that are perfect for the minor promises.

Parallel to the bulky necklaces, designers are fond of enormous finger rings with big faceted gemstones this summer season.



Feel free to surf to my weblog promise rings $250

Anonymous said...

The notion that pearls are made from sand intruding into the shell of an oyster
is phony. One more style and design selection utilizing diamonds to convey pre engagement, friendship
or other commitments include diamond band rings which may have a number of diamonds and therefore are also
very well suited for investing in as matching diamond promise rings.
6) If you or your partner think of jewellery as more of a
female thing, fear not.

Here is my weblog ... promise rings her jared's

Anonymous said...

An alternative for acne medication (plus the subsequent reduced social anxiety) may come
within the form of treatments that produce use of salicylic acid.
Some are nevertheless organic, you might drink them (but this just isn't the recommended use). Dermatologists and alternative treatment practitioners suggest that acne-sufferers should wash the spot twice daily with mild soap. After using this acne cure for a couple of weeks, you will end up amazed at the results.

My web site; acne no more review (mr.kamdrive.info)

Anonymous said...

However, some organic hairdressing products are derived from plant-based materials, which boost shine.
Natural soap is easy and fun to make in the home, possesses no chemicals or ingredients which might be damaging to your skin or even the environment.

Acne, pimples and brown spots are common skin complaints, forms of called as skin blemishes and do affect
appearance of someone negatively, herbal strategy to acne
and dark spots is quite effective and suitable for all types of skin.

The stamp tool it's essentially a brush that, instead of painting an excellent color, samples a certain chunk of pixels from elsewhere inside the document - or even an entirely different document - and clones them upon your image.

my webpage ... makeup for acne (mediatranz.com)

Anonymous said...

I'm form of hoping menopause provides back clear skin, before I have lots of wrinkles so that it is appreciated. I often remove my make-up right when I go back home and know I'm not
heading back out - so my pores don't clog. These infomercials don't address what is happening inside of your body.

The apple cider vinegar treatment toner will decrease the swelling of acne
within one night to three nights.

Stop by my website :: acne quick fixes at home []

Anonymous said...

It is typically helpful to set your video camera in
stain focus mode. Choose a reliable outlet:
There has been so much increase in demand for diamond jewelry
that many outlets have been opened to sell diamond jewelry.
As emerald is an expensive gem they usually come in shapes that help in retaining
maximum weight from raw stone.

my site :: promise rings littman jewelers
()

Anonymous said...

You just have to be certain whom you give the promise ring to.

You must start shopping for your rings at least two
to three months before the D day. By the end I hope it will
be clear on the difference.

my website; promise rings pandora

Anonymous said...

The notion that pearls are made from sand intruding into the shell of an oyster is phony.
The tradition of exchanging rings and them being worn by both men and women as
symbol of marriage came about only toward the twentieth
century. It seems to me Apple is just looking out for
their own public image.

my webpage - webpage []

Anonymous said...

Once you understand a few uncomplicated issues to maintain in intellect, it is possible to take it easy and retail outlet on your cardiovascular's information, with out that anxiety of doing the unsuitable decision or ending up with a bracelet that is not proper available for you. Titanium is not as expensive as silver or gold, but it is much more enduring and just as attractive. The critical element is that the person created the promise to abstain from sex until finally marriage.

My webpage :: promise rings on amazon

Anonymous said...

A promise ring is a kind of commitment to your partner.

They are usually given with the intent of changing into engaged at some purpose within the future.
Also, when the piercing is routinely painful and does not appear
to heal, you must seek cure by your major health attention supplier.


Feel free to surf to my web-site - promise rings under 70$

Anonymous said...

Designs array from designs that can serve as both equally diamond engagement rings and
pre-engagement diamond promise rings as well as distinctive
ring designs. You will discover a number of ornaments that fascinate everyone like
necklaces, bracelets, watches, scarves, rings, handbags, brooches, belts and clips.
But just because there are no junky designs on these rings there is no reason to
overlook comfort too mens titanium wedding rings.

my page - promise rings 100 ()

Anonymous said...

c of the whole crop will consequence in round cultured pearls of the finest quality.
And so they're grown inside lagoons of tiny islands which might be part of a group referred to as French Polynesia. It is why young children's
watches which can be a a part of motion picture merchandise are
so well-known nowadays.

Here is my weblog: promise rings under 75 dollars
- -